Aww well, i want to say, first I did, not mean to pound on Daisy2theMaxx? If I did? But what they went thur ... I had already heard about ... thousands of times!
People paying a small fortune to hire a "Trainer/Behaviourist to fix there dog ... and it is "Money Down the toilet??" It's been more that 15, years now but I remember where I came from! And I had my first Working Line GSD ... neither did I??
Yeah it's a bit much ... but it's a thing. If you have dealt with a dog with "serious send you to the "ER," issues' ... successfully? Wither you know it or not?
One "trainer, looks the same as another if you know nothing??" I was there with my first Working Line GSD, knew nothing for "his issue?" I was a "Mossler, " guy and "Boxers are Mossler Dog's." To be clear and as a general rule they "tend to like people?" My first WL GSD, not so much??
I am not faulting the OP, for their choice of trainers? They did what made sense to them at the time? And they still have there (dog) in there home! So that is a "Win!" But ... in the beginning if, you know nothing? And you have a dog with "issues?" And you know next to nothing about training a dog with "issues??" And you do look for help? Then you "Assume" that Positive Only, IE "Cookies and Treats," Trainers, must be the way to go?? Cuz you know, that is what, "Everybody does?"
Boxer's are "Working Dog's" and "sigh," yes, even the "American Line Dog's?" Now what "Work," they can actually do?? Well that is subject for debate? But there job number (when they were (changed) after WWII for Americans, was to be the "Perfect Family Dog," for "American's." And they excel at that!
Boxer's tend to like "people." You need not do much, they just do. And of the top three ... of "Workingline Dog's," thr "Boxer," is the least likely to get one sued! Top three of the "Best of the Best," for Working Dog's is the "Malinois" the "Best of the Best," hands, down, no debate! Dog two is the WL GSD, and dog number three is the "Boxer."
And out of those three for the Average owner, looking for a "Working Line Dog? The "Boxer," is the least likely to get there owner sued, for biting a stranger!
The WL GSD ... I know, and "I don't recommend them to anyone I know, period end of story." They are great freaking dog's, no doubt but too much dog for most people! The Mal ... LOL, well yeah that would be a hard "NO," from me also. I never had one, I had never met one ... except now I have! He is a pretty Dog _Thor, he get's along great with my "Bella." I luv when he comes to visit ... but the thing is ... he is not my Dog! We have a six between a fence and that fence means nothing to "Thor!"
They are struggling to keep their dog, yard in their yard! We have not seen him visit for a few weeks now?
So they have done something?) But if they want to let him go? I'd luv to have him?
And dog number three, the "Boxer!" LOL, well in the "Working Dog," class, that is the only dog I would recommend to "some people," that said I want a "Working Dog?"
They are "different," not likely to get you sued for biting the "crap out of someone," but if you don't understand them ... they are the most likely to drive an owner "Nut's!"
A lot of "Drive and Energy," and uh well nuttiness. "The Clown Prince of the Dog World," as it were!
Oh and the GSD yeah, when I saw our president was bring two GSD's into the White House??? I said to my wife ... that is not good! And yep sure enough the first dog went back to Delaware (for biting people)! And the second dog at last count has bitten elven people??
An American Line Boxer, would have been a much better/safer choice for visitors ie "New People??" All the time?? Life does not get better then this!
Just saying.